
News Flash — October 25, 2026
October 25, 2026
In a significant reversal, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit has ruled in favor of the federal government's authority to hold immigration detainees indefinitely while their cases are pending, overturning its own prior decision that had placed limits on prolonged civil detention.
The en banc ruling, decided by a divided court, held that the government's interest in ensuring the appearance of detainees at removal proceedings and protecting the public outweighs the liberty interests of individuals held without a fixed release date. The majority opinion declined to impose a presumptive time limit on detention, finding that existing statutory authority permits ICE to continue holding detainees for as long as their immigration proceedings remain unresolved.
The decision is a major setback for immigration advocates and detainees who had relied on the court's earlier ruling to challenge prolonged detention. Under the prior precedent, detainees held for extended periods were entitled to individualized bond hearings at which the government bore the burden of justifying continued custody. That protection is now eliminated within the Fifth Circuit's jurisdiction, which covers Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi — states that together house a substantial share of the nation's immigration detention population.
Dissenting judges warned that the ruling effectively authorizes indefinite imprisonment of civil detainees with no meaningful check on executive power. "The Constitution does not permit the government to lock a person up indefinitely without a meaningful opportunity to contest that detention," wrote one dissenting judge. "Today's decision abandons that principle."
Civil rights organizations have announced plans to seek review before the U.S. Supreme Court. In the meantime, detainees in the Fifth Circuit who were relying on bond hearing rights established under the prior ruling may find those proceedings no longer available to them.
For individuals detained in Texas, Louisiana, or Mississippi, the ruling significantly narrows the legal tools available to challenge continued custody. However, other avenues may still exist, including habeas corpus petitions in federal district court, motions to reopen removal proceedings, and applications for relief that could result in release. If you or a family member is being held in immigration detention, contact our office immediately to discuss your options.
If you have immigration questions, please call us for a consultation at 305-859-0872.